There’s a shift underway for marketing analytics and UX leaders that’s not just technical, but strategic. We’re entering a new era of first-party data where the rules are less about collection and more about connection.

Long gone are the days when third-party cookies quietly stitched together behavioral profiles behind the scenes. Today, the onus is on us — marketers, data strategists and experience designers — to build the kind of digital interactions that people want to log into, contribute to and trust.

And that’s a good thing.

Because when you earn data well, you earn loyalty. For marketers who live and breathe for the complexity of the long, relationship-based sales cycle of the industries that we serve like manufacturing, agriculture and insurance: first-party data isn’t just a tool but a lifeline.

Let’s talk about what’s changing, and what it means for you.

Logged-In Experiences: From Gated Content to Gated Value

If your logged-in experience today is simply a place to download product spec sheets or view policy documents — you’re missing a major opportunity.

In our work, we’re seeing a dramatic shift where logged-in environment user expectations are evolving beyond portals to ecosystems of value.

What does that look like? For manufacturers, it might be a predictive maintenance dashboard powered by IoT data and past purchase history. For insurers, maybe it’s a personalized risk advisor that helps clients optimize coverage based on life events or location-specific risks.

The goal is to create a “give-to-get” relationship where the value behind the login outweighs the cost of sharing personal information. And it needs to be obvious — visibly and viscerally beneficial.

In fact, a recent study from Twilio Segment found that 69% of consumers are willing to share personal data if there’s a clear benefit — like better service, personalized experiences or exclusive content. The problem? Only 40% say brands are delivering that value. Yikes!

Start asking yourself:

  • What do users get in return for their data?
  • How can their experience get better with every interaction?
  • What are we doing to make it easy to say “yes” to personalization?

Related Content: 3 Ways Not to Build Your Database

Value Exchange: It’s Not Just About Discounts

If we think about first-party data as a transaction, then value is the currency.

Think about what your user needs to accomplish in their interactions with your brand and product. Their time is precious, and their pain points are nuanced.

Give them tools that save time or reduce complexity. Deliver insights they can’t get anywhere else. Let them see themselves in your system — and not just as a name on a spreadsheet, but as an individual with preferences, behaviors and intent.

For example:

  • In manufacturing, a dealer portal that remembers a user’s last equipment orders, recommends compatible parts and provides warranty timelines is more valuable than a 10% off promo code.
  • In insurance, giving policyholders an AI-powered scenario planner (“What if I retire early? What if I move across state lines?”) gives them agency — and helps your team deepen the relationship through predictive data inputs.

We often talk about “knowing the customer,” but now the customer has to know that we know.

Related Content: How to Get Actionable Insights From Raw Data

Identity Management: The Backbone of Personalization

All of this sounds great until you’re dealing with multiple CRM systems, product databases, policy systems and customer portals that don’t talk to each other.

Sound familiar?

In heavily matrixed organizations with distributor networks, identity resolution is one of the biggest barriers to first-party data success. A single customer may show up as five different records across systems. Or worse — they’re just an email in one and a phone number in another.

The solution isn’t a quick fix. But it starts with a shift in mindset:

  • Prioritize a unified customer ID across platforms. This may mean investing in a Customer Data Platform (CDP) or working with IT and data teams to connect your martech stack via API integrations. The goal: one source of truth that recognizes a user whether they log in from mobile, web or call center.
  • Treat identity as an experience, not just a backend process. Users notice when systems don’t recognize them, when preferences reset or when they have to repeat the same info. That friction erodes trust and makes people less likely to share more in the future.

The experience of being “known” should be invisible and delightful. Think: seamless re-authentication, remembered preferences, contextual content — all powered by a clean identity graph behind the scenes.

Related Content: From Data to Delivery: Mastering Personalization in Marketing

Compliance Isn’t the End — It’s the Floor

We’ve all met the legal and compliance experts and know the bar is high. Whether it’s HIPAA, CCPA, GDPR or industry-specific regulations, data collection must be ethical, secure and transparent.

But the truth is that compliance doesn’t build trust. Transparency does.

Users don’t read privacy policies. They feel privacy through frictionless interactions, clear opt-ins and controls that empower them.

Some best practices we’re seeing rise to the top:

  • Progressive profiling: Instead of asking for everything upfront, build the data profile over time as trust grows.
  • Custom consent management: Offer granular control over how users’ data is used — not just “accept” or “decline.”
  • Explain why data is collected. (“We ask about your fleet size so we can recommend service intervals tailored to your usage.”)

The more you treat compliance as a part of the experience design, the more users feel in control — and the more they’ll engage.

Where to Start (or Refocus)

If this feels like a lot — good. It should. First-party data isn’t a checkbox project. It’s a cultural shift across marketing, sales, IT and customer service.

But you don’t have to do it all at once.

Here’s where we often recommend teams focus first:

      1. Audit your logged-in experiences. Are they valuable enough to justify sharing data? If not, what needs to change?
      2. Define your value exchange. What are you offering in return for data? How do you communicate that value?
      3. Map your customer identity journey. Where are the gaps? Where does data get lost or duplicated? Start there.
      4. Partner with legal and compliance early. Not as a gatekeeper — but as a collaborator in designing ethical, user-first experiences.
      5. Get cross-functional. First-party data lives at the intersection of UX, analytics, IT and brand. Get everyone talking early and often.

In a time when data breaches dominate headlines and privacy feels precarious, the most radical thing we can do as marketers is earn trust.

Not just through messaging — but through every interaction, every login, every helpful suggestion based on real, clean, voluntarily given data.

That’s the future of first-party data. And for industries like ours — complex, high-value, relationship-driven — it’s not just a trend. It’s a mandate.

Let’s build better experiences. Let’s be better stewards of the data we’re given. And let’s never forget that the customer doesn’t owe us anything. But if we create something worth engaging in — they just might offer everything we need.